Skip to main content

Anthem by Ayn Rand: Individualism vs Collectivism (reaction pre-pandemic)

I read Anthem by Ayn Rand before the pandemic happened. So my thoughts and opinions are not colored by people's reaction to the pandemic (e.g. anti-maskers). 



First off, I disagree with Ms. Rand's over-arching thesis that selfishness is always good. Too much individuality has made me feel alienated from other people. The best feelings that I had are when I feel connected to other people.

The following quote resonated with me because I'm usually secretive with my thoughts and opinions. I don't share my thoughts freely that's why i have a private twitter account.

It is a sin to write this. It is a sin to think words no others think and to put them down upon a paper no others are to see. It is base and evil. It is as if we were speaking alone to no ears but our own.

But according to the "document, don't create" philosophy you should share to the world your progress and don't just keep it to yourself.

You might as well get constructive feedback and meet kindred spirits.

But you know, some of the statements in the book are true somewhat if we change the qualifier from all to some. I am an individualist by practice but i find collectivist philosophy fascinating.

This quote is even more relevant now than before.

This is our wonder and our secret fear, that we know and do not resist.

There are instances where my individualistic tendencies backfired. If I shared them with someone, they would have warned me. But to whom am i going to share that? I don't share...

This could also apply to EJK, graft and corruption, etc. Turning a blind eye, trying not to stir the pot, maintaining the status quo.

This speaks to me because I'm non-confrontational. I try to avoid it as much as possible.

It was not that the learning was too hard for us. It was that the learning was too easy.
 
Teaching high school math is boring for me because it is too easy and not challenging enough.

This is a great sin, to be born with a head which is too quick.
I love learning but i'm rarely consistent about it. So I wrote that I should commit to some military-like regimen, and if I quit, I pay.

But we wish no end to our quest. We wish nothing, save to be alone and to learn, and to feel as if with each day our sight were growing sharper than the hawk’s and clearer than rock crystal.
This conjures an image of Sisyphus happily rolling the boulder up the hill.

That feeling when something is so enjoyable you don't want it to end. Even if it's challenging.

I imagine Alfred N. Whitehead has this to say to Ayn Rand's philosophy.

The misconception which has haunted philosophic literature throughout the centuries is the notion of 'independent existence.'

There is no such mode of existence; every entity is to be understood in terms of the way it is interwoven with the rest of the universe.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hierarchy of D-classes determined by rank

The D-classes have a certain type of hierarchy. And to illustrate this, I'll give relevant properties of the rank of a transformation. The first property is that the rank of a product of two transformations is less than or equal to the minimum of the individual ranks. Let's flesh this out some more. Let's start with what I call the nobility in this hierarchy--the permutations. The noble class would like their wealth and power to stay within their class or family. How do they do that? The idea is to marry someone with the same social class as you are. It's a very common trope in movies and TV. So in the same way, for an "offspring" of a permutation to have the full rank still, both of its "parents" should be permutations. rank(ab)=n  if and only if rank(a)=rank(b)=n As part of group theory, we study permutations. This is because a group is embedded in a permutation group by Cayley's theorem. In the finite case, every group of order n is isomorphi...

I can't finish watching Laggies...

Why am I bothered by Laggies ? So much so that I don’t like finishing it? I guess the main character is about to make wrong decisions. And that gives me anxiety. I’m screaming at the screen, “No! Don’t do that”. But of course, they still do. Of course. I already know how this is gonna end. Why does it bother me so much when technically she’s not doing anything wrong? Oh yes, she’s gonna hurt her fiance when she inevitably breaks off their engagement. And? I don’t know. As I said, I don’t like it when characters make wrong decisions.  She’s running away because she discovered that her father is having an affair. And instead of confronting him, she’s living with a teenager and her dad. And of course, she’s gonna fall in love with the dad. Predictable. I guess I just don’t like it when I don’t have control over things. The question is: will my worrying ever change the outcome? No. Definitely not. It’s all predetermined. But why am I worried on behalf of the main character? Even if she...